Reviews
Rate Show
Very hard to describe this show
The humor is unmatched. Fun story, engaging mystery, outstanding narration, and most of all it’s brilliantly weird! That ending was absolutely beautiful. Executed perfectly
- freakazoid4807
- Oct. 16, 2024
Really enjoying this podcast
I think it’s skillfully written and I admire how well it’s voice acted. I’m enjoying it immensely and I recommend it highly.
- Bzxk
- July 23, 2024
In love
I've been in love since the first episode, the storytelling it's incredible and even though it talks about dark themes it's not too heavy to listen. I keep quoting this pod on daily basis. Love it
Very entertaining!
A clever dark comedy that had my imagination resurrected from it's dormancy. Thank you
The Milkman of St. Gaff’s
This podcast is what would happen if Andy Griffith met the Twilight Zone. It’s a Kafkaesque Candide. A Lovecraftian Moral Orel. If any of that sounds like your kind of thing, I cannot recommend this highly enough.
- Hippiepotamus0
- Oct. 30, 2023
Yes!
The way that this one man band has managed to create a beautifully atmospheric and surreal story with great voice acting for every character, but especially Howie, is beyond me. The use of the 1st person narrative, which I don’t see a lot in podcasts, is used amazingly to establish the unreliable narrator and always leaves me a little unsure of what is actually real and what is Howie hallucinating. Dark but in a cheerfully light way. The glowing whale bones religion holds a special place in my heart.
- TheExParrot
- June 19, 2022
Very hard to describe this show
The humor is unmatched. Fun story, engaging mystery, outstanding narration, and most of all it’s brilliantly weird! Only complaint is that I have to wait 2 weeks for a new episode.
- freakazoid4807
- April 22, 2022
- Keirasmommy1
- April 12, 2022
Plucky Doom
My favorite kind of entertainment is the kind that manages to combine two opposite qualities into one gripping product. I mean, life is pretty much a bunch of elements that shouldn't work together but must. I like the Milkman of St. Gaffs's because it expertly pulls off the feeling of two things existing at once: dread and politeness. You feel it when you listen and that's about the best I can say about any entertainment!
- Finding Pattersby
- March 20, 2022
Lovecraft meets Kafka Fantasy Horror!
When I read the description and heard the Trailer of this Podcast, I Knew that I had to listen.
It’s a kooky premise (MILKMEN!) and I love the Narrator’s Voice.
I found this HIDDEN GEM via Twitter. Every Sunday I go looking for new Fiction using #AudioDramaSunday ! Then I share the wealth on Podcast Recommendation sites like LIKEWISE & Goodpods.
Not ALL of the BEST are on the Top of Apple Podcasts Lists. We will get them there.
- Tante143
- March 6, 2022
THE MORE I LISTENED….
The more I listened the more I had to hear. I gave the first episode some ear. I kind of scoffed and said, “At least give the second episode a chance.” That is how it went for me. It turned out, I really enjoyed this podcast. This was a pretty good adventure.
It was really nice, give it a try.
- Chesstiger139
- Feb. 4, 2022
Wow, what a great trip!
I start a lot of podcasts. Looking for immersive fiction, fantasy, and humor. This one nailed everything. To date it’s the only podcast I’ve listened to every single episode of…and I listened to them about as back to back as life would allow. Kudos to the writer/actor, what a fun awesome story in a fun awesome world. If you like dark and strange storytelling, give this one a try!
- shgreen123
- Nov. 27, 2021
Amazing solo podcast
Amazing that this podcast is all accomplished by one man, great writing with an *unreliable narrator*, great sound editing, atmosphere, story and honestly, everything in between. I had been holding out to fully support on Patreon and reviewing but found myself unable to resist, even if this podcast doesn’t take over the world it has already established itself as a positively influential element on my life, give it the good old college try on a few commutes even if it starts a little slow you’ll be hooked before you know it!
- AlcoholicStepfather
- Nov. 19, 2021
Fun
I like this show a lot! It has been a fun story to listen to and I am very curious to hear more!!!
- CitizenTrent
- Oct. 25, 2021
Weird and Wonderful
Engaging, unreliable narrator, fascinating premise, bit by bit worldbuilding leaves me wanting more. Instantly hooked on this lovingly crafted independent podcast.
- Kai RM
- Oct. 20, 2021
Fascinating
Howie is an amazing unreliable narrator, someone who approaches his (admittedly unsettling) surroundings so off-kilter that it’s hard to ever be sure how his problems are going to resolve. It’s by turns uncomfortable, funny, and horrible, and I’m hooked.
- marsupialFruitcake
- Sept. 13, 2021
Brilliant
Unique, lighthearted within a dark, unfolding premise. A captivating blend of many emotions. Very well executed. My favorite podcast.
- Piecemeal
- June 11, 2021
Great podcast
Eerie and it’s own way. Very well written. Very strange. Definitely in my top 10 audio dramas
- MomCallsMeNicholas
- April 10, 2021
The Milkman of St. Gaff’s
Shows like this are why I love audio dramas. Expertly written, with a healthy dose of dark humor.
- Subjective Opinions
- Jan. 30, 2021
Very happy to have found this one!
Strange Lovecraftian tale. Well written and well paced. I’m hooked.
- skylarkishome
- Nov. 13, 2020